July 31, 2015
WASHINGTON. The top leaders of the National Catholic Committee on Scouting have made an uneasy peace with the Boy Scouts of America’s decision July 27 to allow openly gay troop leaders and employees to serve in their ranks at the national level.
The Boy Scouts’ decision does not affect decisions about leaders made by local troops and councils and also permits religiously chartered Scout troops to choose leaders whose values are consistent with those of the sponsoring faith.
“It is not entirely clear how these rights will be squared with previous policy changes the Boy Scouts have made ... but it appears that the resolution respects the needs of Catholic-chartered organizations in the right to choose leaders whose character and conduct are consistent with those of Catholic teaching,” said a July 27 statement from Edward Martin, national chairman, and Father Michael Hanifin, national chaplain, for the National Catholic Committee on Scouting.
“At the same time, we express strong concern about the practical implications of this resolution, especially for our young people in Scouting, and whether the term ‘sexual orientation’ will be correctly understood and applied only in reference to sexual inclination and not to sexual conduct or behavior,” they said.
“The resolution also affirms a chartered organization’s right to select its unit leaders based on its religious principles, rejects any interference with that right, and provides that local Scout councils will not interfere with chartered organizations’ rights in this regard,” said a July 28 statement from Bishop Robert E. Guglielmone of Charleston, South Carolina. “As chartering organizations, individual parishes, institutions and Catholic schools have always had this right.”
In their statement, Martin and Father Hanifin said they also were concerned that the new resolution “articulates a position on adult sexual conduct that does not make clear that sexual behavior should be reserved to a husband and a wife in marriage.”
They described an “increasingly challenging” situation with regard to differences in religious and societal beliefs that led to the policy change, but added: “We recognize the vital importance of providing a Catholic emphasis to Catholic Scouts and Scouters seeking ways to live out their ‘duty to God.’
“Our youth don’t want to leave Scouting. ... Let’s continue this important journey together and pray for the future of Scouting!” Martin and Father Hanifin said.
The Boy Scouts’ decision to allow gay leaders didn’t come as a surprise to Jim Guschke, a parishioner at Holy Rosary Church in Donelson and chairman of the Catholic Committee on Scouting for the Diocese of Nashville. After the Scouts permitted gay youth to be admitted, Guschke said, “the conversation turned to when are we going to have the acceptance of gay leaders.”
Guschke thought a lawsuit challenging the ban on gay scouting leaders would have been filed already, he added, but “it never came.”
During a recent leadership training meeting sponsored by National Catholic Committee on Scouting, Guschke said, there was discussion that under the law, Catholic schools and organizations like the Knights of Columbus who sponsor charters for a Boy Scout troop might not qualify as a religious organization. If that’s the case, the charter might have to be transferred to the parish in order to be protected, Guschke said.
The sexual preference of leaders and scouts is not an issue that would be questioned when someone applies to be registered with a troop, Guschke said. There is no question about sexual preference on the application, he noted. “It does not come up now. Literally, there’s no reason for it to come up.”
If it becomes an issue for troops chartered by Catholic parishes, schools or organizations, Guschke said, “We’ll go where Nashville Bishop (David) Choby goes with this thing … and support him in whatever his decision is.”
About 70 percent of Boy Scout troops are run by faith-based groups.
The Mormon church, whose troops account for 17 percent of all Boy Scouts, strongly criticized the policy change.
“The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is deeply troubled by today’s vote,” said a July 27 news release. “When the leadership of the church resumes its regular schedule of meetings in August, the century-long association with Scouting will need to be examined.”
The statement said the church has been examining alternatives, especially for Mormon boys who live in areas without a Boy Scouts presence.
Guschke said he doesn’t plan on leaving the Scouts.
“I’ve been registered with Boy Scouts for almost 30 years now. There’s a passion I hold about it. It’s tied to my faith as a Catholic. The scout oath says duty to God first. It’s deeply ingrained,” Guschke said. “I’m not going anywhere.”
The new policy was crafted by the Scouts’ top leaders, including Robert Gates, the former defense secretary who is now the Scouts’ president. According to the Scouts, 79 percent of its executive board members on a July 27 conference call approved the new policy.
The numbers of Boy Scouts has been slipping in recent years. Faced with criticism over the organization’s policies toward gays, as well as lawsuits against the Boy Scouts and declining business support, the Scouts allowed openly gay youths to join in 2013. Membership dropped 6 percent that year, and slipped another 7 percent last year to 2.4 million. The drop was attributed to departures by some evangelical churches over the 2013 policy change.
When a Boy Scouts committee unanimously recommended July 13 that the ban on gay troop leaders and employees be rescinded, the Southern Baptist Convention looked askance at the move.
Russell Moore, president of the denomination’s Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission, predicted an even greater exodus of Baptists from the Scouts, and expressed skepticism the Scouts would hold the line on protecting the rights of churches and other religious institutions.
“At every point, the Scout leadership tells us that they will go this far and no farther, but here we are again – so it’s hard for me to believe, in the long term, that the Boy Scouts will allow religious groups to have the freedom to choose their own leaders,” Moore told Baptist Press July 14. “In recent years I have seen a definite cooling on the part of Baptist churches toward the Scouts. This will probably bring that cooling to a freeze.”
Andy Telli of the Tennessee Register contributed to this report.